Circular Action Alliance sent its revised California packaging plan to CalRecycle on Tuesday, October 13. Inside it are the first proposed 2027 producer fee rates for brands selling into the state. CalRecycle now has 75 calendar days to approve the plan, reject it, approve it with conditions, or ask for more information. That clock runs out in late December. (CalRecycle, SB 54 program page)
California's Packaging Producer Responsibility Advisory Board took the plan up on Friday, October 16, in Sacramento. Under Public Resources Code 42070(h) the board has 60 calendar days from receipt to file written comments, closing in mid-December. (CalRecycle, advisory board)
The numbers are large. CAA's revised budget puts 2027 program costs near $1.11 billion, down from $1.87 billion in the draft. The five-year estimate now runs from $7.81 billion to $13.1 billion, against $9.35 billion to $17.2 billion before. (Waste Dive, October 14)
These programs charge by material and by weight. The box you ship orders in is rated material.
Oregon already publishes the rate card
California's rates are still proposals. Oregon's are live. CAA's 2026 Oregon Producer Fee Schedule, published October 29, 2025, sets rates across 60 material categories. These are the lines a fulfillment operation actually touches.
| Covered material | 2026 Oregon rate |
|---|---|
| Corrugated cardboard | 8.0 cents per pound |
| Corrugated cardboard, tertiary transport, non-consumer | 0.0 cents per pound |
| Kraft paper | 8.0 cents per pound |
| Paperboard | 8.0 cents per pound |
| Paper, small format | 44.0 cents per pound |
| HDPE and LDPE flexible and film items | 43.0 cents per pound |
| Pallet wrap, non-consumer | 34.0 cents per pound |
| White expanded foam cushioning | 72.0 cents per pound |
| Colored expanded foam cushioning | 138.0 cents per pound |
| Plastic laminates and other flexible plastic packaging | 102.0 cents per pound |
Source: CAA 2026 Oregon Producer Fee Schedule
Read the first two rows again. Corrugated that reaches a consumer is rated at 8 cents a pound. The same corrugated moving as non-consumer transport packaging is zero. What separates them is who opens the box. Every carton you ship to a customer sits on the paid side of that line.
Weight decides this
The rate column invites you to chase the cheapest material. That is usually wrong, because the fee is assessed per pound and weight swamps the rate difference.
Work a half-pound corrugated shipper. At 8 cents a pound, Oregon's fee is 4 cents. Now work a poly mailer at half an ounce. Film is rated more than five times higher at 43 cents a pound, but the mailer weighs a sixteenth as much, so the fee lands near 1.3 cents.
The material with the scary rate costs about a third as much per order. Our position: rank your packaging by grams per order, not by cents per pound. The rate card only matters once weight is settled.
Foam is the exception, because rate and weight both move against you. Colored expanded foam cushioning at 138 cents a pound is more than 17 times the corrugated rate, and foam blocks are not weightless.
Where the thresholds sit
California let producers with under $1 million in California gross sales apply for a small producer exemption, though claiming it still required registering with CalRecycle. Producers had to pick a compliance path by June 1, 2026, either by joining CAA or by registering with CalRecycle to comply on their own. Baseline producer reports were due July 1, 2026. (Mayer Brown, June 1, 2026)
Oregon sizes it differently. Under ORS 459A.884(6), producers with gross revenues below $10 million who supply more than five metric tons into Oregon, or the reverse, may elect a tiered flat fee instead of per-pound rates.
A brand shipping 1,000 to 25,000 orders a month is almost certainly past California's $1 million threshold. Confirm your status with each program instead of assuming it.
What this means for your brand
Four things are worth doing before January.
Weigh the packaging itself. Pull tare weights for every carton size, mailer, void fill, and roll of tape you run, then multiply by your order volume into states with live programs. That is your fee base, and most brands have never calculated it.
Find out who is registered as the producer for your shipments. If nobody checked, nobody is registered.
Right-size before Q1. Fee exposure and dimensional weight reward the same change. A carton two inches smaller cuts the weight your carrier bills and the pounds a program invoices.
Put a 2027 California invoice in the cash plan. The rates are still under review, but the program is built to bill next year.
Packaging is one of the few fulfillment costs a brand can still move. Carrier pricing climbs on a schedule nobody outside the carrier controls, as the parcel fuel surcharge math showed. Grams per order is yours.
This also lands with your 3PL more than your packaging vendor. We select the carton sizes and buy the corrugated for the brands we run out of Canal Winchester, so right-sizing is a conversation with your account team instead of a procurement project. Our ecommerce fulfillment and kitting and assembly teams can run the swap in January rather than mid-peak. If you want your packaging weights pulled and totaled, get in touch.
FAQ
Does this apply if I ship from Ohio?
Yes, when your packages land in a state with a program. The obligation follows the destination, not the warehouse. Ohio has no packaging EPR law. Seven states have enacted one, and the start dates are staggered well past 2027. (EPR Atlas, updated October 18, 2026)
Is my 3PL the producer or am I?
Usually the brand owner. The programs define producer through a hierarchy, and CalRecycle publishes a screening tool for working out where you land. Do not assume your fulfillment partner carries the registration. Ask, and get the answer in writing.
Will switching to paper void fill lower my fee?
Per pound in Oregon, yes. Kraft paper is rated at 8 cents against 43 cents for film and 72 cents for white foam cushioning. Whether your total drops depends on grams, because paper fill can weigh more than air pillows for the same cavity. Weigh both before you commit.
What happens if CalRecycle rejects the plan?
CalRecycle has more options than a yes or no, including approving with conditions or setting its own timeline for deciding. Any of those pushes final 2027 rates later into the year. That argues for building your fee base now instead of waiting on a published number.