A report announced today puts a number on something a lot of brands felt last quarter but could not prove. Parcel rates went down. Almost nobody's invoice went down with them.
Deposco published its Q3 Commerce Signal report on October 15 with data through September 30, and announced the findings Wednesday, October 21. Carrier rates fell 3.3% per package from the second quarter. What shippers actually paid fell 0.6%. (Deposco, October 21)
"Rates came down, but operators didn't feel it. That's the story of the quarter," said Eric Lemus, the company's vice president of strategy and data analytics.
An outside index found the same gap on a different set of shippers. The TD Cowen/AFS Freight Index put ground parcel cost per package down 2.6% from the second quarter, and still 5.2% above where it sat a year earlier.
The relief went into the packages
A rate card is a price for one package at one weight, one service level, one zone, and one address type. Change any of those inputs and the rate card can fall while your bill rises.
That is what happened. Deposco attributes the missing relief to heavier packages and faster service selections. More deliveries went to residential addresses, which carry their own surcharge on every major carrier.
The monthly numbers show how little actually moved. Market parcel cost per package ran $10.35 in July and $10.42 in August before settling at $10.36 in September, according to the report itself. That is not a quarter of falling costs. That is a quarter of flat costs that only looks like a decline when you compare the average against a more expensive Q2.
Demand held up better than dollars. Deposco put GMV growth at 11.7% and order growth at 5.3% at the quarter's close. Parcel inflation cooled to 6.9% year over year, down from 12.9%. Selling price inflation came in at 1.1%. Brands are still absorbing parcel costs faster than they are raising prices.
The window already closed
Anyone planning to budget Q4 off a quieter Q3 invoice should stop. The quarter that just ended was the cheap one.
AFS projects ground parcel cost per package will hit 43.3% above its January 2018 baseline in the fourth quarter. That is an all-time high, up 3.2% from Q3 and 5.8% year over year. (AFS Logistics, October 13) We covered the fuel surcharge piece of that index last week.
Peak demand surcharges start October 25. That is Sunday. Deposco expects the volume ramp to begin the week of November 9 and peak during the weeks of November 28 and December 5, at nearly twice the September order rate.
Four checks worth running this week
The useful response to this report is not a feeling about rates. It is a look at your own invoice.
- Pull one SKU across both quarters. Same item, same destination zone, same service. If the per-package cost did not fall, your rate card was never the problem.
- Count your residential share. DTC brands run high here by nature. The number matters because it is the line item that scales with every order and never shows up in a quoted rate.
- Compare billed weight to packed weight. Dimensional weight charges you for the box, not the product. A package that gained an ounce of void fill can gain a full billable pound.
- Audit your service mix. Expedited selections creep in through free shipping thresholds and checkout defaults. Faster service was one of the two things that ate the rate decrease.
What this means for your brand
For a brand shipping 1,000 to 25,000 orders a month, the rate card is mostly fixed. You are not renegotiating published rates at that volume. The inputs are where the money is.
Zone is the biggest one, and it is decided by geography rather than by negotiation. We ship from Canal Winchester, Ohio, in the Columbus metro. Roughly 60% of the US and Canadian population sits within 600 miles, and 90% of customers are reached in two days by ground. A package that leaves from central Ohio crosses fewer zones than the same package leaving a coastal warehouse, which lowers the rate before any discount applies. That is the part of our ecommerce fulfillment math that holds up whether carrier rates rise or fall.
The second one is packaging discipline. Right-sizing boxes and controlling void fill is unglamorous work that directly reduces billable weight. Our warehouse and storage team sizes cartons per SKU rather than per order profile.
Orders are processed within 24 hours, which keeps a late-October surcharge start from compounding into a missed delivery window. If you want to know what your real cost per order looks like before the November 9 ramp, get in touch.
FAQ
My 3PL quoted me a lower rate this quarter. Why did my bill go up?
Almost certainly mix. A lower published rate applies to one specific combination of weight, zone, service level, and address type. If your average package got heavier or more orders went expedited, the quoted improvement never reaches the invoice. The same holds if your customer base shifted further from the warehouse. Ask for a cost-per-package breakdown by zone instead of a blended average.
Should I expect rates to keep falling into next year?
The Q3 decline looks like an exception rather than a trend. Fourth-quarter costs are projected to set a record and peak surcharges begin October 25. Crude oil sat about 40% above its July low in mid-October, so the fuel component is working against you too. Budget for a more expensive Q4 than Q3. More detail on how we handle volume spikes is on our FAQ page.