Cargo Theft 2026: Losses Up 39%, Incidents Down 25%

Moby Dick 3PL Team •

Verisk published its third-quarter cargo theft analysis on Wednesday, November 4. Two numbers in it move in opposite directions. Reported thefts across the United States and Canada fell 25 percent through September, to 2,072. Estimated losses over those same nine months rose 39 percent, to $718.9 million. (Verisk, November 4, 2026)

Fewer loads are being stolen. The ones that go are worth far more.

Fewer thefts, much bigger ones

The average value of a stolen shipment reached $448,456, up from $261,115 a year earlier. That is a 72 percent jump. In the third quarter alone, 19 thefts carried documented values of $1 million or more, against nine in the third quarter of 2025. (Claims Journal, November 5, 2026)

Quarterly incidents came in at 547, down 33 percent year over year and down 19 percent from the second quarter. Quarterly losses still climbed to $230.1 million from $205.1 million.

So the risk changed shape. Your odds of getting hit went down. The cost of the hit that lands went up a lot.

Risk you can average across a year is a budget line. Risk that arrives once and removes a quarter of your inventory needs a different answer, and November is when most DTC brands have the most inventory value sitting in the fewest loads.

A quarter of the quarter was someone posing as your carrier

The method shifted too. Fictitious pickups, where someone uses paperwork and a believable identity to collect a load they have no claim to, hit 138 incidents. That is roughly 25 percent of all activity, up from 18 percent.

Keith Lewis, VP of operations at Verisk CargoNet, called the quarter "mixed results," with reported incidents down while "the estimated financial impact grew significantly." He pointed to identity verification and shipment visibility as the controls that matter most as cargo values climb. (Truck News, November 5, 2026)

Take that as an operational instruction. A quarter of this problem gets settled at the dock, by whoever is standing there when a driver arrives. Trailer locks do nothing about it.

Four things that belong in your 3PL's receiving procedure before Thanksgiving:

  • The warehouse holds the pickup number and releases it to the driver on arrival, never ahead of time by email.
  • The driver's name and tractor number get checked against what the broker sent, not against what the driver says.
  • Any same-day change to a scheduled carrier triggers a callback to a number already on file, not to the number in the new email.
  • Loads that sit through a closure get counted and photographed on the way in and on the way out.

None of that costs money. All of it fails when nobody owns it.

CargoNet also flagged the fourth quarter and the weeks after it, citing the pattern of elevated activity around holidays when facilities close for days and staffing thins. Your inventory will sit through two long closures between now and January.

Where the loads disappear

Theft stays geographically concentrated. California recorded 182 incidents in the third quarter. New Jersey had 46, Texas 43, and Illinois 40. Those four states accounted for about 57 percent of the quarter's reported incidents. California by itself was a third of them.

The commodity mix is worth a look if you sell physical consumer goods. Food and beverage remained the most-targeted category at 94 incidents, down sharply from 178 a year earlier. Metals came next at 63, including 34 copper thefts. Electronics logged 46. Cosmetics rose to 14 from nine.

Cosmetics is a small number on a long list, and it is the direction of travel. Small, easily resold goods are what this year's thieves select for, and that describes much of what sits in DTC warehouses.

What this means for your brand

If you ship 1,000 to 25,000 orders a month, your exposure here is almost entirely inbound. Nobody is stealing outbound parcels in volumes that show up in this report. Containers and full truckloads of your best seller are the target.

Two decisions follow.

The first is geography. Inventory in the two highest-theft states carries a different risk profile than inventory outside them, and plenty of brands split stock into California and New Jersey for delivery speed without pricing that in. Moby Dick operates from Canal Winchester in the Columbus metro, which is not on CargoNet's list and still reaches 90 percent of US customers in two days by ground, with 60 percent of the US and Canadian population inside 600 miles. Our Columbus location exists for the zone math. The theft map is a second argument for it.

The second is who verifies a pickup. Ask your 3PL today what happens when a driver shows up a day early with correct-looking paperwork and a tractor number nobody recognizes. If the answer involves checking that against a source the warehouse already had, you are covered. If the answer is that the load goes out, fix it this week. Our fulfillment operation runs inbound receiving as its own procedure with its own counts, and orders still process within 24 hours through peak.

Beauty and cosmetics brands should look hardest, since they are moving up that list while most other categories move down it.

To walk through how your inbound freight gets received and released, get in touch.

FAQ

Does this report mean my shipments are safer than last year?

A given load is less likely to be stolen than it was a year ago. The financial consequence when it happens is much worse. Incidents fell 25 percent through September while losses rose 39 percent. Verify and insure at the load level rather than relaxing.

Is cargo theft a parcel problem or a freight problem?

Almost entirely freight. CargoNet tracks truckload and less-than-truckload shipments, warehouse pickups, and the paperwork fraud around them. For a DTC brand that puts the risk between your manufacturer or port and your 3PL's dock, not on the individual packages going out to customers.

Fulfillment Questions? Ask a Real Human.

Moby Dick 3PL is a boutique fulfillment partner in Columbus, Ohio for brands shipping 1,000 to 25,000 orders a month. We answer the phone.