Corrugated demand fell this year. Corrugated prices went up anyway, in three separate rounds.
Packaging Corporation of America put both facts in the same filing. North American corrugated shipments were down 1.6 percent in the third quarter against the same quarter of 2025, and industry containerboard production was down 1.6 percent. Over those same three months, PCA's domestic containerboard prices ran 11.5 percent above a year earlier. (PCA Form 10-Q, filed November 5, 2026)
The Justice Department is now asking how that happened.
What showed up in last week's filings
Four containerboard producers have received grand jury subpoenas from the DOJ Antitrust Division. Three of them disclosed it in SEC filings on November 4 and November 5. Cascades, which reports in Canada, confirmed a September 25 subpoena in the same week. (Packaging Dive, November 4, 2026, updated November 6)
Smurfit Westrock's filing is the most specific. It received its subpoena on September 22 "in connection with a grand jury investigation in the Northern District of Illinois regarding the pricing and sale of containerboard and related products." The company says it is fully cooperating and believes its practices have complied with US antitrust laws. It also told investors "it is possible that an adverse outcome could have a material impact" on its financial condition. (Smurfit Westrock Form 10-Q, filed November 4, 2026)
International Paper received its subpoena on September 24, from the same grand jury in the same district. (International Paper Form 10-Q, filed November 4, 2026) PCA dated its own to "late September" and described the request as documents "relating to its business," without naming the product.
A civil case got there first. Twelve containerboard producers were named in a class action filed July 29, 2025 in the Northern District of Illinois, which alleges the defendants conspired from November 1, 2020 onward to fix prices on containerboard and on finished packaging made from containerboard. The class, as the complaint describes it, covers buyers who purchased containerboard products directly from one or more defendants. Smurfit Westrock's motion to dismiss was denied on September 4, 2026.
The ladder your box quotes climbed
PCA's filing lays out the year in reported index prices. Linerboard and corrugating medium each rose a net $20 a ton in the first quarter. Another $80 a ton landed in the second quarter. In September, reported linerboard rose $70 a ton and corrugating medium rose $100.
That is $170 a ton on linerboard and $200 on medium in nine months.
What the producers asked for was larger. PCA sought $140 a ton effective September 1. Cascades sought $110 on linerboard and $140 on medium. Smurfit Westrock sought $100 and International Paper sought $80. (Packaging Gateway, September 8, 2026)
Put those two paragraphs side by side. Producers announced $140 and the index moved $70. An announced increase is a request, and roughly half of September's request stuck. If your converter passed through the full announced number, you paid for a price the market never cleared.
Why supply stayed tight while demand fell
Roughly 3.9 million tons of US containerboard capacity was permanently removed between February 2025 and March 2026, close to 10 percent of national capacity, per Fastmarkets data cited in the same report. PCA's filing puts industry containerboard inventories at 2.59 million tons at the end of September, down 6.1 percent year over year.
Capacity came out faster than orders did. That is the industry's explanation for prices rising into a shrinking market, and it is the explanation a grand jury in Chicago will now test.
What this means for your brand
The September move has not finished reaching you. PCA told investors that fourth-quarter prices "are expected to improve as we continue to implement earlier price increases." Box quotes for December and January are still catching up to a board price that moved in September.
Four things worth doing in the next two weeks:
Get the pass-through in writing. Ask your converter which announced increase they applied, against which index, on what date, and when the next review lands. A $140 pass-through on a $70 index move is worth a phone call.
Re-measure your cartons. Board cost scales with square inches. So does dimensional weight. A carton that drops one size cuts the corrugated bill and the billable weight at the same time, and that is the only lever here that pays twice.
Pull Q1 packaging forward. Quotes reset in January with the September increase fully baked in. Inventory bought now sits at the older number.
Know whether you buy direct. The class described in the complaint covers direct purchasers from a defendant producer. Most brands buy through a converter or a 3PL instead. Ask your own counsel whether that distinction matters for you.
For the brands we run out of Canal Winchester, the corrugated is ours to buy, which makes carton sizing part of the fulfillment conversation rather than a separate procurement project. Our ecommerce fulfillment and kitting and assembly teams can run a size audit against your actual order mix, and warehouse storage is where a pre-January buy goes. We covered the other packaging line item, California's EPR fees for 2027, last month. If you want your top cartons measured and priced, get in touch.
FAQ
Does a DOJ investigation mean box prices come down?
Not on its own, and not soon. Grand jury investigations run for months or years, and no producer has been charged with anything. Near-term price direction still comes from capacity and demand, and both currently point up.
What is the fastest way to cut packaging cost per order?
Ship fewer sizes and ship them smaller. Most brands carry cartons that were right for an older product mix, and the savings land in board cost, dimensional weight, void fill, and storage cube at once.